Martha’s Vineyard is one of the most exclusive and popular summer destinations on the East Coast. Residents take great pride in keeping the town in its classic Americana glory. From picturesque malt shops to coastal walkways to white picket fences, it paints a truly idyllic portrait.
Unfortunately, you might be waiting a while before booking your Vineyard trip.
Not only is Martha’s Vineyard a pricey destination, but it’s also highly exclusive. The population jumps from around 50,000 to 200,000 every summer, which makes finding lodging (especially affordable lodging) even more difficult.
In other words, you might not make the cut—but that might not be a bad thing.
After all, who wants to rub elbows with over 200,000 tourists during high season? If you’re anything like me, you want all the cute charm of the Vineyard without any of the fuss or noise. Thankfully, it’s far from being the only classy island destination on the East Coast.
I’ve found some of the best Martha’s Vineyard alternatives for you—all of which are located in Maine. It might not be the first state that pops into your mind when you think of refined getaways, but the state’s slogan is ‘the way life should be’—and I think that’s about all the introduction this highly rural and northern outpost needs.
Feeling a little blue about missing out on another summer getaway to the Vineyard? Don’t be. You’re going to Maine, baby!
Monhegan Island, Maine
This tiny island has a population of around 60 year-round residents. The picturesque landscape has lured in artists for well over a century. In fact, this is one of New England’s most prominent stopovers for painters—so bring your easel, if you’re so inclined! You can set up anywhere, and you’ll likely spot other creatives doing their thing.
The island is home to a handful of inns and cottages, many of which are booked for summer. Keep in mind that this is a particularly remote getaway. There are no cars and little pavement, meaning social butterflies might not get their fill. Hikers can rejoice, though, as trails blanket the island.
Hotel & Airbnb recommendations:
Peaks Island, Maine
This island is accessible straight from Portland, the capital of Maine. After a short boat ride, you’ll be transported into a wonderful and rugged little island town. Similar to Monhegan, there’s a strong (if smaller) artistic community.
However, the emphasis is on getting outdoors. Locals flock to the island during the summer months to watch birds, relax on the beach, kayak, and even ride horses. If you have limited time to enjoy summer island life, then this is a highly accessible Martha’s Vineyard alternative.
I recommend staying at:
Chebeague Island, Maine
North of Peaks Island and Portland is Chebeague Island. It’s one of hundreds of islands that make up Casco Bay, many of which are great for harvesting clams and mussels. So long as you avoid red tide season, you can gorge yourself on some of the freshest seafood the US has to offer.
That’s right—this is chowder country. If you’re thinking of heading to the East Coast in search of fresh food, then this is ground zero. Aside from snacking your way across the island, you can find plenty of outdoor and water activities. There’s also a nine-hole golf course that’s open to the public.
Here’s where to stay:
Vinalhaven, Maine
When you arrive in Vinalhaven, you’ll probably notice a fleet of small boats first. These are some of Maine’s premier lobster-fishing vessels, which bring in some of the tastiest catches in the US. Aside from its seas, Vinalhaven is also known for its natural wonders.
This island is a bit larger than others on the list. You’ll have access to around two dozen nature reserves and hiking trails, along with three lighthouses. Aside from that, the island is home to two major rock quarries, which have since been filled in with water and opened for swimming. You can canoe, kayak, and otherwise enjoy these quarries-turned-oases.
Options for lodging in Vinalhaven:
Kennebunkport, Maine
This historic fishing village has become one of Maine’s premier summer destinations. Unlike others on this list, Kennebunkport isn’t an island. Instead, it’s located on the coastline between New Hampshire’s Portsmouth and Maine’s Portland, which means the population stays high year-round.
The town center is very scenic for those in search of small-town charm. There are also plenty of bed and breakfasts and boutique stays to choose from. You’ll also notice plenty of favorites from Martha’s Vineyard, including antique shops, art galleries, coffee shops, and boutique stores.
Hotel and Airbnb recommendations:
Which Martha’s Vineyard alternative comes out ahead?
I’ve checked the data and I’ve skimmed the hotel recommendations one last time. As a writer, the artsy and secluded vibes of Monhegan call to me. Plus, it’s a tiny island with no roads and no cars. That’s a huge plus.
Aside from Monhegan, I’m intrigued by the quarries-turned-swimming holes in Vinalhaven. I grew up in Missouri where this kind of repurposing happens, and the waters were always crystal clear. Plus, who doesn’t love a good water adventure?
But my ultimate selection has to be the Mongolian yurt on Chebeague Island. Aside from my interest in next-level clam chowder, I also love alternative lodging options, especially glamping-adjacent ones. I’ve stayed in yurts before and they’re wonderful. I’d love to stay here for a week or two (at least, in summer).