West Virginia doesn’t often land high on the list of travel destinations for Americans.
Videos by TravelAwaits
Usually, visitors stop by to check out spots like the New River Gorge National Park and Preserve, along with its famed bridge. It’s definitely a worthy stopover for anyone who appreciates rafting, hiking, and otherwise delving into nature. Considering the area was once decimated for coal mining, Fayetteville’s surrounding wonders are also a (much-needed) reminder that nature bounces back—often faster than we think is possible.
That being said, don’t skip out on Fayetteville if you’re heading to the New River Gorge to take on the area’s many outdoor adventures.
Yes, it’s a tiny town home to only a few thousand residents, much smaller than West Virginia’s capital city of Charleston. But it’s authentic, vibrant, and welcoming—which are usually three key components that travelers look for when venturing off the beaten path.
You can find live music, restaurants serving up comfort food, and even join in on local festivals, including Heritage Day (held around the Fourth of July) and Bridge Day (held on the third Saturday of every October).
Despite its small size, you can also find beautiful Airbnbs in Fayetteville that capitalize on the area’s stunning forests. Whether you’re looking for a classic cabin or a modern A-Frame, you’ve got options.
[This article is part of TravelAwaits new Airbnb and Vrbo recommendation series. We dig into listings to identify the crème de la crème of Guest Favorites, Superhost listings, and hidden gems to make finding the perfect rental for your next trip a breeze.]
Best Airbnbs in Fayetteville, West Virginia: quick list
- A spa setup for weary hikers: Cozy Downtown Home
- An easy setup for families: Modern 1940s Bungalow
- A wacky ode to local lore: Mothman-Themed House
- A historic creekside cabin: Cabin at Laurel Creek
- A blast for all ages: Family Fun House
- An affordable tiny home: New River Gorge Tiny House
- A no-frills setup: Goose Creek Retreat
Airbnbs in Fayetteville, West Virginia for an affordable small-town fall trip
Cozy Downtown Home
As outlined above, New River Gorge National Park is one of the top reasons that travelers find themselves in Fayetteville. If that’s the case, and you plan on hiking your way across the park, you might want an Airbnb that has spa features. This home has three perks that weary hikers will love: a state-of-the-art barrel sauna, a relaxing outdoor fire pit with comfortable chairs, and a vinyl collection that will set the mood for a cozy evening. As an added perk, this home is also walkable to Fayetteville. Just make sure to bring your walking shoes.
Modern 1940s Bungalow
Originally built in the 1940s, this two-bedroom home has been updated with contemporary features and accents, like the renovated kitchen and the in-unit laundry. It’s a great option for families heading to NRG, as it’s located between town and the area’s top hiking trails and river access points. The added privacy also makes enjoying the outdoor spaces even better, from the furnished fire pit out back to the covered patio in front. Just be aware that the second bedroom has a queen-sized bed, not two twins.
Mothman Themed House
If you’ve never heard of the Mothman, let me catch you up quickly. In the mid-1960s, groups of West Virginia locals began reporting run-ins with a monster that looked half-man and half-moth. The sightings coincided with a major bridge collapse that killed 46 people, leading many in the paranormal community to announce that West Virginia had its very own harbinger of death: The Mothman.
If you’re into that type of local lore, you’ll love this two-bedroom home. It’s covered in Gothic décor that touches on the many myths and rumors surrounding the Mothman. Kitschy setup aside, there’s also a very cool escape room hidden in the garage, along with a game room that travelers who are young at heart will enjoy. The outdoor fire pit and hammock are a great counterbalance to the home’s darkly interior.
Cabin at Laurel Creek
Regardless of which Airbnbs in Fayetteville catch your eye, you’re sure to be impressed by one thing when you visit: the surrounding forest. If getting out into nature is important to you, check out this two-bedroom home. It’s on a private plot of forested land that has a creek running through it. The property has a large deck, grill setup, and fire pit that lets you maximize your time below the trees. As a perk, the home also has plenty of historic flair, having been built back in 1900. It has a classic cottage feel that you’ll remember.
Family Fun House
If you’re heading to the area with family, you might want an Airbnb that has something guests of all ages will enjoy. This three-bedroom home sleeps up to 11 with a bunk-bed room and a sofa bed in the living room. The main house has clean, modern furnishings that make hangout sessions and group meals a breeze.
Outside, there’s a fire pit and a hot tub that visitors of all ages will enjoy. But the game room is sure to be the biggest hit—it’s got a ping pong table, arcade games, and neon lights that kids will adore. Lastly, like the other family-friendly unit on this list, this home is close to all the major hiking trails and access points for a breezy adventure in New River Gorge National Park.
New River Gorge Tiny House
If you’re okay with small spaces, you’ll save big on this tiny home. Despite its small size, the front covered porch gives you the chance to enjoy the outdoors and also have a functional, compact full kitchen. You’ve got your own private acreage to enjoy, home to a healthy forest, fire pit, and gas grill. You can also sleep a third guest on the pullout sofa—but the mattress is firm. This unit is great for those on a budget who plan to spend most of their time outdoors.
Goose Creek Retreat
This two-bedroom home has everything you could want from an affordable Airbnb in Fayetteville. It’s located right between Fayetteville and New River Gorge National Park, putting you close to both. There are two comfortable bedrooms where you can expect quality rest after a long day. Out back, there’s a large patio with a grill and a dining setup, which is surrounded by mature trees. Out front, there’s a covered patio with rocking chairs. No frills, no fuss—just a reliably great stay.
[Just a heads-up: We may earn an affiliate commission when you make a purchase from a link in our articles.]