Madison, Wisconsin has a reputation for being family-friendly, stable, and home to a vibrant community-focused lifestyle. You might have also heard that it’s got great beer, hearty dishes that will get you through winter, and a love of football.
Videos by TravelAwaits
But if you cut to the core of Madison, you’ll find a strong emphasis on the great outdoors.
The city is located between the Mendota and Monona Lakes, giving you total water access. It’s also got over 200 miles of hiking and cycling trails, along with dozens of parks where you can lie back in the grass and enjoy the fresh air.
And though the winters are tough, the fall season is a treat. The farmers’ markets are perfect weekend fare, along with the area’s pumpkin patches and apple orchards. Toss in seasonal food festivals and restaurants with heated patios, and you’ve got just about everything you could need for a cozy fall getaway.
All you need is a charming place to stay. Start with these autumn-friendly Airbnbs in Madison, Wisconsin.
[This article is part of TravelAwaits new Airbnb and Vrbo recommendation series. We dig into listings to identify the crème de la crème of Guest Favorites, Superhost listings, and hidden gems to make finding the perfect rental for your next trip a breeze.]
Best Airbnbs in Madison, Wisconsin: short list
- Great for couples: Historic Guesthouse
- Cozy historic stay: Historic Cottage
- Landmark historic home: Historic Downtown House
- A budget-friendly spot: Groovy Stay Off Atwood
- A walkable neighborhood: Private Garden Flat
- Best location: Boutique Eco Hideaway
- Top spa amenities: Cottage Suite
- A flashy gem: Lake Monona Haven
7 Airbnbs in Madison, Wisconsin this autumn
Historic Guesthouse
The first three Airbnbs in Madison, Wisconsin that I’m recommending are historic. This cozy guesthouse dates back to 1916 and is part of the National Register of Historic Places. You can expect peace and quiet in the calming gardens where leaves transform colors each autumn. Inside, you can rest up while appreciating historic Prairie woodwork. The one-bedroom setup is ideal for couples who want some rest, but you can also sleep two more on a pullout in the living room.
Historic Cottage
This historic cottage was built in the 1850s right on Lake Mendota, giving you an almost-lakefront location near Capitol Square. But the unit also comes with a private fenced back yard that’s ideal for sipping on tea while enjoying the fall foliage. Inside, the home includes original marble-tiled bathrooms, a farmhouse kitchen, and other reclaimed fixtures, including original artwork. Notably, this historic cottage also has a luxurious, high-design feel, perfect for any travelers with expensive tastes.
Historic Downtown House
With three bedrooms and plenty of space to stretch out, this historic downtown stay is perfect for groups of up to five. The landmarked home was built over 150 years ago, with high ceilings and natural light in each room. The home is just steps away from Lake Mendota and is west-facing, letting you soak up Madison’s best sunsets. As with the last historic stay, expect a gorgeous high-design feel inside that maximizes its historic charm.
Groovy Stay Off Atwood
This two-bedroom stay sleeps up to six guests and, though it takes you further from Madison’s historic downtown area, it’s budget-friendly. The home sits on a quiet street off Atwood, where you can enjoy two floors all to yourself, along with a patio and fire pit. The home is a little dated (there are carpets throughout), but comes with retro-style perks like a vintage stereo console and some vinyl to play.
Private Garden Flat
You’ll get more out of this retreat thanks to its location in Madison’s East End. The area is extremely walkable, home to popular shops and restaurants that come alive with the autumn harvest spirit. The garden-level unit (see: basement with windows) has two bedrooms and a kitchenette that covers all the basics. The unit also has a washer-dryer, making it great for longer stays.
Boutique Eco Hideaway
The unit above (Private Garden Flat) has a great location in the walkable East End area of Madison—but this one-bedroom hideaway puts you in the heart of the Willy Street neighborhood, just steps from Lake Monona and BB Clarke Beach Park. The home is beautifully decorated with upscale, spa-like pieces that give it a boutique feel. There’s also a charming garden in the back where you can sip by the fire pit, surrounded by colorful autumn foliage.
Cottage Suite
If you’re looking for actual spa-caliber amenities instead of spa-like décor, go with this two-bedroom guest suite. The home has a boho-style covered porch where you can unwind after a long day, along with a furnished backyard with a fire pit. But the real perks are the sauna and hot tub where you can unwind at your leisure. As a perk, the home is also located in the walkable, scenic East End neighborhood.
Lake Monona Haven
It doesn’t get much more OTT than the Downtown Lake Monona Haven. This three-bedroom guest suite is decked out with flashy features, from the hot tub to the lakeside fire pit to the barrel sauna. Yes, it has a luxury price tag to match—but if you want to take full advantage of Madison during the colorful autumn season, it’s hard to beat this right-on-the-water escape. Plus, you can sleep seven guests in three bedrooms, letting you split the final price.
[Just a heads-up: We may earn an affiliate commission when you make a purchase from a link in our articles.]