• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

TravelAwaits

Our mission is to serve the 50+ traveler who's ready to cross a few items off their bucket list.

  • Destinations
    • United States
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Canada
    • Mexico and Caribbean
    • Central and South America
    • Australia and South Pacific
    • Africa
    • Middle East
    • Antarctica and Arctic
    • See All
  • Activities & Interests
    • History and Culture
    • Outdoor Activities
    • Food and Drink
    • Sightseeing
    • Seasonal Travel
    • National Parks
    • State Parks
    • Hotels and Resorts
    • Wildlife
    • Beaches
    • Shopping
    • Festivals and Special Events
    • Theme Parks
    • Photography
    • Reading
    • See All
  • Types of Travel
    • Cruises and Sailing
    • Road Trips
    • Group Travel
    • RVing
    • Camping
    • Rail
    • Wellness Travel
    • Adventure Travel
    • Ancestry Travel
    • Naturism
    • LGBTQ+ Travel
    • Budget Travel
    • Weekend Getaway
    • Bucket List Trips
    • Family Vacations
    • Solo Travel
    • Full-Time Travel
    • Pet-Friendly Travel
    • See All
  • News & Tips
    • Travel News
    • Travel Tips
    • Travel Products
    • Travel With Confidence
    • Gift Guides
    • See All
  • Inspire
  • Retire
  • Best Of Travel Awards
View of Cayuga Lake from the Pair Of Cayuga Cabin Rentals
  • Destinations
  • United States
  • New York
  • The Finger Lakes
  • Activities and Interests
  • Hotels and Resorts
  • Vacation Rentals
  • DestinationsUnited StatesNew YorkThe Finger Lakes

    10 Luxurious Finger Lakes Cabin Rentals On The Water

    William Stupp
    September 27, 2022

    Upstate New York has many natural spectacles, appealing sights that draw people away from the great cities of the Northeast to greener and wilder pastures. The Finger Lakes is one such gem, a region of water, wine, and wonder.

    Videos by TravelAwaits

    Formed by glaciers over the past 2 million years, the region consists of 11 lakes just south of Lake Ontario. The name comes from the fact that the lakes are much longer than they are wide (as is typical for glacial lakes).

    The pleasures of spending time on the water, whether fishing, paddling, swimming, or idling, need not be elaborated upon. But there’s much more to do in the region. Many enjoy making short road trips on the 5/20 route which passes a number of roadside attractions and wineries. 

    Situated on the southern tip of Lake Seneca, Watkins Glen has wine trails, state parks, hikes, and waterfalls. Indeed, there are over 50 waterfalls in the region, all worth checking out between meals at local restaurants and visits to historical sites and museums.

    A short spell of living a simpler life, even if just for a few days, can do much to rejuvenate the body and mind. The placid waters of the Finger Lakes is a great place to find what you’re looking for, whatever that may be.

    Continue reading to learn about 10 Vrbo vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes. Each property has lakefront access and Upstate charm.

    Sunset Haven$196/nightly avg

    A mid-century home enmeshed in a millennia-old landscape, Sunset Haven offers couples and small groups a joyous getaway at Lake Cayuga. A string of memorable moments will unfold as you sit out on the lake or enjoy the scene from the open-plan living room. The home has a dock and an outdoor patio complete with a large hot tub. It is a homey affair, nothing fancy, but guests will find it stylish nonetheless. In addition to the master, there is a room occupied by queen, twin, and trundle beds.

    Dreaming of Aurora – your dream vacation awaits you
    54 reviews
    Cottage
    6 Guests
    2 Bedrooms
    1 Bathroom
    Top guest reviews
    All was good.
    We had such a lovely week! It was relaxing, the property was wonderful, and the lake was so much fun! Would definitely visit again!
    Overall house and location were great! Only two things to think of. Tons of storage, but no room to put anything away in bedrooms and bathroom. Second thing is the air conditioning in the main room. Even with all the blinds pulled and fans running it can be incredibly warm in the living space. House is clean and very well stocked in the kitchen. Plenty of extra towels if needed.
    Our group of 5 had 3 March birthdays. It was a perfect excuse to plan a girl’s weekend. The home was as beautiful in person as it was online. We loved the hot tub and appreciated the well stocked house. Everything from booking to check in and out was so simple. Would definitely stay again!
    We had such a great experience at Sunset Haven. Paul and Debbie were so helpful, quick to respond and understanding given weather/road conditions. The lake views and hot tub were the highlight of the trip, especially after all day snowboarding at Greek Peak – the woodstove was great for keeping us warm and setting such a cozy setting. The hosts had everything we needed in the kitchen, bathroom and bedrooms – a must stay and we will absolutely return to enjoy the dock and lake in the summertime.
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 196
    View Deal

    Seneca Memories$334/nightly avg

    Take in Seneca Lake from this lovely cottage on the western shore. The home has high ceilings and plenty of windows. From the kitchen cabinets to the dressers, the home is fitted with many examples of fine craftsmanship. The home gym and the dining room are surrounded by lake-facing windows on three sides. There are four bedrooms with queen or king beds (one of which is a Murphy bed) and each bedroom has its own bathroom. Naturally, the house has outdoor seating, a dock, and access to watercraft.

    Dreaming of Penn Yan – your dream vacation awaits you
    6 reviews
    Cottage
    10 Guests
    4 Bedrooms
    5 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    Great stay
    This location is a gem – clean, spacious, beautiful – and you can’t beat the views from the incredible master suite! We would stay here again in a heartbeat. I gave 4 stars on the check-in-process only, as it was really a challenge for us to use the front door keypad (multiple people tried – and finally – only 1 person in our group had success with the fingerprint style). However, the realty group was extremely responsive – and we had no issues otherwise.
    My family had a wonderful time staying at this immaculate and spacious house. We loved the spectacular view of the lake and close proximity to several vineyards!
    We thoroughly enjoyed staying at this beautiful lake house. The home was clean and very pretty, the kitchen was full of great appliances and utensils (except lacking some teaspoons) and we cooked in every night. Grill was new. All the beds were comfortable except the main floor master bedroom. That mattress has a huge dip in the middle of it that we had to try to support using pillows and blankets.Plenty of towels for everyone to use. Welcome basket was a pleasant surprise.The only minor critiques I have are that one of the blinds in the main floor porch did not work and blocked large large portion of our view of the lake which was a bit of a bummer. Also, it was disconcerting when we first arrived as the path to get to the house was a dirt road that went through a long winding farm. It felt like you were in the middle of nowhere. It turned out to be a very sweet cozy little area that was peaceful and charming but I think I would’ve felt better knowing how tucked away it was in a remote area.Finally, we found all sorts of fun things to do in the area but the property managers did not respond well when I asked them to give me some ideas of things to do prior to our arrival.Overall, it was a wonderful stay in a beautiful home that I would definitely recommend to other out-of-town visitors.
    Everything was amazing! The house was beautiful, everything there you needed! I would say the only down fall was the person that went into clean it before. There was food left in the fridge and the counter wasn’t clean. Other then that everything was amazing!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 334
    View Deal

    Renovated Cabin At The Waters’ Edge$400/nightly avg

    Located in the quiet town of Branchport at the northwestern end of Keuka Lake, this quaint cabin is your gateway to the joys of the entire Finger Lakes region. The town’s marina is just three doors down should you wish to rent a boat to moor at the home’s private dock. The home is a comfortable one enhanced by views of the lake. It has three bedrooms, a kitchen that is both spacious and stylish, and lovely outdoor sitting areas on the grass and deck.

    Dreaming of Branchport – your dream vacation awaits you
    72 reviews
    Cabin
    6 Guests
    3 Bedrooms
    2 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    We were in the area for three days of wine touring. The cabin is absolutely lovely and very stylish. The view of the lake is great and the location perfect for getting to the best of the Keuka Lake wineries. Great hosts too!
    Beautiful location and well decorated cottage. The owner was so gracious and left special treats. Incredible hospitality. Hope to return!
    Wonderful❤️ everything we could need for a short getaway. Quiet area on the lake
    We had a fun time staying at The Cabin. A storm had damaged the dock but Loretta,the property manager who lived next door, was very kind and we were allowed to use her dock to tie up the pontoon boat and fish off the dock. She even shared her paddle boat with us. The Cabin was beautiful and Lynda, the owner had supplied us with all the starter necessities and a great gift basket. The s’mores were a big hit with our granddaughter. We also had our dogs with us and they loved swimming in the lake. They gave it 4 paws up. I would highly recommend this if you were looking for a rental.
    Loved the location, accommodations and cleanliness. All you could need and more is there for you. Truly a special place. Will be back. Loretta is warm, attentive, and welcoming. Made our family getaway so wonderful. Counting the days until we return!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 400
    View Deal

    Peaceful Paradise On Lake Cayuga$675/nightly avg

    Just 20 minutes north of Ithaca, this waterfront house rental is great for groups with business in that city who cherish a secluded base. Whether you’re coming for a graduation, family retreat, or just to experience the idyllic wine country, this four-bedroom house is full of opportunities for water lovers. It has a dock, canoes, kayaks, and inflatables. There’s also a ping-pong table for terrestrial fun. The great room is enhanced by a beautiful decorative fireplace of warped stone and there are places to dine indoors and out.

    Dreaming of Lansing – your dream vacation awaits you
    18 reviews
    Cottage
    12 Guests
    4 Bedrooms
    2 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    Nice place with great lake views
    House was in excellent condition and very clean. Well-designed for outdoor entertaining. Beautiful views and quiet area.
    The house and property exceeded our expectations.
    Thank you so much for making the first vrbo house and stay so perfect. The views were amazing and the house was so comfortable and offered so many things to do and had the extra amenities that made our stay just perfect.
    Absolutely beautiful house. Right by the water. Perfect amount of space. Property was well maintained. Immediately responded when we asked for more supplies (i.e. towels).Thanks for the wonderful stay!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 675
    View Deal

    White O’Morn$540/nightly avg

    From the eastern shores of Lake Owasco a sunset is more than just a pretty sight; it is a sign that you are in the right place. Such is the scene every evening at White O’Morn, a cozy three-bedroom cabin in the Finger Lakes. Up to eight guests can discover the local charms from the comfort of this three-bedroom home. It has a deck, dock, living area, and a kitchen with all the convenient features you enjoy at home (plus gorgeous granite countertops that may even rival your own in terms of beauty).

    Dreaming of Auburn – your dream vacation awaits you
    91 reviews
    Cottage
    8 Guests
    3 Bedrooms
    2 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    We had a fantastic stay! The house was a good size for 6 people, the outdoor seating areas are great, the best part was access to the water for fishing and swimming right from the dock. The location is great, close to restaurants, stores etc. We absolutely recommend!
    Another lovely summer week in this comfortable spacious home
    We loved our stay there. When you walk out onto the deck the view of the lake is breathtaking. We had campfires around the fire pit and watched the sunset every night. The dock was great to tie our boat rental to. It is a beautiful lake to cruise up and down. We spent the whole week on the lake, swimming, kayaking, boating and fishing. Definitely plan on going back.
    Beautiful property in a quiet neighborhood, yet only minutes drive from Skaneateles and Auburn. Easy to run to the store or the bakery. Close to fitness facilities, parks, and restaurants. Large shallow area of waterfront for swimming/wading with convenient steps off the dock into the water. Property is well maintained. We had a wonderful time this week!
    From the time we walked in we were amazed… beautiful home, gorgeous view and awesome host. The sunsets were postcard worthy! I loved how you could just relax by the water or go enjoy some of the local attractions. We had such a wonderful time we have already booked again for next year! Thank you for sharing your home which allowed us to make great memories with friends and family.
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 540
    View Deal

    O’Cottage$648/nightly avg

    Your family and friends will surely thank you for booking this fantastic four-bedroom cottage on Lake Keuka. It comes with everything you need for summer fun: a fire pit, kayaks, inflatables, and a swimming platform that the kids will love. The ground floor is kept afloat by beautiful timber beams and has multiple living areas for those days when you can’t agree on what to watch or which games to play. A private queen bedroom is detached from the rest of the second floor. Across the house and above the kitchen, three more bedrooms are to be found: two more queens and a dormitory with five beds. Best of all, each bedroom has views of the lake.

    Dreaming of Keuka Park – your dream vacation awaits you
    64 reviews
    Private vacation home
    12 Guests
    4 Bedrooms
    3 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    We had a great week at keuka lake. Cottage had everything we needed for the week. It was spacious & comfortable for our family of 8. Location is premium! Will definitely be back!
    We had a great time and really enjoyed the house and waterfront. The driveway was definitely steep but we never had any issues even with a Toyota Prius. Our kids loved the floating raft and spent many hours in the water. It was also so nice to be on a quiet secluded section of the road, it all felt very private. The owner was really helpful and available. Would definitely recommend.
    We really enjoyed our week at the cottage for the 4th of July. It was incredible to see multiple fireworks displays over the lake while sitting around the fire pit. The kids spent a lot of time in the water. We rented a boat for the week from East Bluff Marina, which was a fantastic addition to the experience. The only issue we had during our stay was a septic smell in the side yard which we communicated to the owner. She let us know that this could be remedied by less use of the system and encouraged using the outdoor shower, which we started doing more. I had worried that not having a dishwasher would be an issue given the size of our group (6 adults, 5 kids), but it was fine and we enjoyed having paper plates for kindling each evening. We boated over to the Switzerland Inn for dinner one night, which was surprisingly quick. Overall, a great stay at a very picturesque spot!
    A group of college friends have been going to the Finger Lakes for several years and always stay in different properties. We had a great trip and highly recommend this property. Just remember to bring sheets and towels as some of us didn’t read this in the description. While we usually pick a new property every year, we would be tempted to return in 2022. Thanks
    The house was adorable, clean and exactly as the photos showed. Listening to the night sounds and the lake, I felt at home with nature and the world! I am already looking forward to my next stay!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 648
    View Deal

    Keuka Blue$800/nightly avg

    A beautiful vacation home on a beautiful lake, Keuka Blue is an elegant home on the western branch of Lake Keuka. It stuns inside and out but is especially appealing when viewed from the water. There are plenty of opportunities to take it from such vantage points as the cottage is stocked with canoes and kayaks (motor boats and watersports craft can be rented nearby). External staircases provide added privacy to each of the three bedrooms while connecting all of the home’s fabulous outdoor areas. This great location has Adirondack chairs, a fire pit, a dock, and bunting; all the things an Upstate cottage ought to have.

    Dreaming of Pulteney – your dream vacation awaits you
    56 reviews
    Cottage
    7 Guests
    3 Bedrooms
    3 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    It was a great stay at Keuka Blue. House was clean and just as described in the listing. Great location, 15 minutes to Hammondsport. Owners were great prior and during the stay.
    Our family really enjoyed this lovely house. The location on the lake is perfect, it is super close to numerous restaurants, vineyards, and activities. Gene was great about providing us with any information we might need about the property. He was also quick to answer if we had any questions. There are a large number of outdoor spaces that are beautifully designed and the landscaping is gorgeous. We really enjoyed the dock area with the walk down stairs to the water. It was perfect for swimming and using the canoe and kayaks provided. We had a lovely time in this home.
    Exceeded our expectations. Great experience and look forward to returning in the future
    We had a great stay at this house. We loved the layout of the house, the decks, and how close it is to the water. Would absolutely stay again.
    This was our second year coming back in a row because we loved our time last year so much. Easy, lovely hosts and a really comfortable house right on the water. Hoping to come back again next year!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 800
    View Deal

    Modern Log Cabin On Skaneateles Lake$727/nightly avg

    A contemporary structure with a delightfully rustic feel, this log cabin is a surefire ticket to an enjoyable family vacation. The property (which can only be accessed by 4-wheel drive) has 200 feet of lakefront property, spacious deck areas (on the water and attached to the home), and a well-developed firepit which everyone will want to gather around.

    The delights don’t end at the front door. The interior is an ecosystem of rock and wood, an homage to the local surroundings done up in the classic log cabin style and complete with a wood-burning fireplace in the great room. The house has two kids’ rooms with twins, two queen rooms, and a workout room. The owners will offer up their pontoon boat to interested guests.

    Dreaming of Skaneateles – your dream vacation awaits you
    61 reviews
    Cabin
    10 Guests
    4 Bedrooms
    3 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    Paul’s cabin was a great place to stay on a beautiful lake. Skaneateles is a wonderful place and staying at Paul’s cabin made the trip an experience to remember.
    This was our first family vacation since our children were little. The cabin was perfect for us. There was plenty of room to gather both inside and out. The trip down to and up from the lake was a bit challenging as was the drive in, but that said it was wonderful to have family time in a beautiful setting! Thank you Paul and crew!~The Barrett Brigade
    The house was amazing and everyone in the family enjoyed it. We can’t wait to go back!
    Amazing property towards the south end of skaneateles lake. Right on the water with all of the amenities you need to cook, grill and relax in the hot tub after enjoying a day on one of the cleanest lakes in the country. We look forward to being back next year!
    What a magical cabin in the woods! We were so impressed with the indoor and outdoor living spaces. We spent most of our time outside, on the deck, on the dock, at the fire pit, in the hot tub and, of course, on the lake. Driveway was definitely a challenge. Also have to mention the property manager, Mike. Mike went above and beyond to make sure our stay was perfect!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 727
    View Deal

    Stunning Skaneateles Home$956/nightly avg

    The glacial lakes are doubtless the highlight of the Finger Lakes region, but there are other wonders to see. One such marvel is this extraordinary house on Lake Skaneateles. It is not only an architectural stunner but also a practical venue for family fun. Children will enjoy climbing the spiral staircase up to the tower, and everyone can appreciate the views.

    The master bedroom has an ensuite with a jacuzzi bathtub. The second bedroom, with its own balcony, is excellent as well. A third room on the ground level will serve well as the children’s room. With so many superb spots to take in the beauty of the lake, some guests might even struggle with getting up to go out on the water.

    Dreaming of Homer – your dream vacation awaits you
    60 reviews
    Private vacation home
    10 Guests
    3 Bedrooms
    3 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    Really enjoyed the house. Had everything we needed to enjoy the stay. Ian reached out to make sure we had what we needed to get into the property – great host! Spending time down on the dock was very nice for the sunny days we did have.
    We had a gathering of family and friends and the gorgeous property and beautiful home were the perfect place to enjoy food and drink and the lake! Very well appointed and extremely comfortable!! Everyone enjoyed immensely and all of us were sorry we couldn’t stay longer. Ian was very responsive and flexible and we hope to return next year. Highly recommend this property!!
    We had a wonderful time and the property was luxurious and serene. The house itself and the path to the shore are vertical by design and so folks with problems with stairs or mobility issues might have trouble. We were fine but our 78 year-old mom struggled. Ian the homeowner is warm and responsive. overall a truly decadent, beautiful place.
    Ian’s place is absolutely stunning – just as amazing as the pictures. We had a lovely weekend on the water, and hope to return! Thank you!
    Ian was a gracious host! His property is absolutely breathtaking, and nothing beats those lake views easily seen throughout the entire house. The private dock by water was so peaceful and calming, as we were serenaded by birds and the ripple sounds of the water. It was such a wonderful experience, and we are happy to have booked this property for a relaxing family getaway!
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 956
    View Deal

    Pair Of Cayuga Cabins$1,250/nightly avg

    Arranging trips for large groups is tough, but the prospect is made much easier by properties like this one, a pair of two pet-friendly cabins on Cayuga Lake. Recent renovations spruced up the outdoor space, which is grand because the views and atmosphere outside are terrific. The main cabin has a master suite, a queen bedroom, an upstairs loft with twins, and a stunning moose head over the fireplace which any hunter will envy. The basement doubles as a game room and bedroom. The second cabin has two bedrooms and a den. Both buildings have rustic wooden fixtures. The lakefront land includes a swimming cove, dock, boat hoist, and four kayaks to play with.

    Dreaming of Lansing – your dream vacation awaits you
    104 reviews
    Cabin
    16 Guests
    6 Bedrooms
    4 Bathrooms
    Top guest reviews
    This house was spectacular! Perfect for a group of 14. Great views of the lake, fire pit, wrap around deck, close to Cayuga wine trail and all of the others! Host and property manager were awesome. Everyone in the group had an amazing stay. Highly recommend!
    My 8 girlfriends and I, all over 60 years old, spent four nights at this beautiful property in early October 2022. The entire process went very smoothly, from our initial inquiries, to booking, to arrival and departure. Our stay was more than we could have hoped for, thanks to the terrific accommodations. The home and grounds are lovely, the kitchen well equipped, the living areas and bedrooms were comfortable. We loved being able to sit together, all of us, on the side deck, at the fire pit, at the dining room table, etc. Everything about our stay went smoothly, thanks to the attention to detail by the property owner.
    The property was rustic in a positive way — it was exactly what we were looking for. It was our first experience renting a house and bringing our dogs and it could not have been better. The house and property is well kept, the kitchen well stocked and the owner was super helpful.
    Great experience. Covered deck was wonderful. Outstanding kitchen. Love the Moosehead over the fireplace
    This was a great spot for our family. The setting and outdoor space are wonderful. The large wrap around deck, fire pit and lake area where our favorite spots! House was very clean and a nice spot for a group or family. Steve, the host, was very responsive and gave us some great recommendations for the area.
    Read Less ∧
    Read More ∨
    from USD 1,250
    View Deal

    To discover even more things to do in and around The Finger Lakes, check out:

    • 7 Fabulous Food Finds In The Finger Lakes
    • 13 Gorgeous Wineries To Visit In The Finger Lakes

    Primary Sidebar

    Recommended Articles

    Travel Tips for Nordic & Scandinavian Countries: Culture, Currency, & More
    Sink Your Teeth into These Acclaimed Dallas Steakhouses
    Must-See Alaska Beaches: Black Sands, Wildlife Sightings, & More
    My Top 20 Luggage Picks for Carry-Ons, Check-Ins, & More—Plus, Shopping Tips
    Sign up for our newsletter
    It's our time to explore
    Our mission is to serve the 50+ traveler
    We want to inspire you to explore new destinations, discover new experiences and savor the journey. Our goal, to share the world’s unique, hidden and once in a lifetime locations with you to create unforgettable memories.
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    Do Not Sell My Personal Information Change Consent