Mystic, Connecticut, is one of the state’s best autumn getaways—even if you’re not into maritime history.
Videos by TravelAwaits
The town hosts a handful of seasonal festivals that capitalize on the fair weather, fall foliage, and famous eats. (Plus, other unexpected fairs like the Pirate Invasion and the Garlic Festival.) The Mystic area is also home to natural corridors that are a treat in September and October, from BF Clyde’s Cyder Mill to Denison Pequotsepos Nature Center.
In town, you can also enjoy shops like Alice’s Haunted Little Bookshop as you wander Olde Mistick Village. When you’re ready to stretch your legs, you can enjoy nearby trails… or head to one of the area’s wineries, which come alive during the harvest season.
But you’ll need a central place to stay while you soak up the seasonal activities—and you might want a rental with a little extra autumn flair. Check out these Vrbos in Mystic, Connecticut if you’re after added charm.
[This article is part of TravelAwaits’ new Airbnb and Vrbo recommendation series. We dig into listings to identify the crème de la crème of Guest Favorites, Superhost listings, and hidden gems, making it easy to find the perfect rental for your next trip.]
Best Vrbos in Mystic, Connecticut this fall:
- Victorian Townhouse: Most central location
- Historic Townhouse: Best design
- 1890s Downtown Mystic House: Unbeatable outdoor space
- Historic House in Downtown Mystic: Perfect for large groups
- Arden House: Luxury vibes
- Sea Captain’s House: Ideal for water-lovers
- Charming 1845 Home: Most charming stay
- Boho Retreat: The simple-and-sweet pick
- Harbor View Landing: Best for couples
Vrbos in Mystic, Connecticut perfect for an autumn trip
Victorian Townhouse
Walkability is an important factor to consider in Mystic, Connecticut. During autumn, you can crisscross the old town and the marina while enjoying the weather and festivities. This two-bedroom historic home puts you right in the heart of Mystic, letting you walk to major attractions, shops, and restaurants. But location is just the start—this Vrbo offers gorgeous marble tiling, a copper soaking tub, and walk-in rain showers. In other words, you’ve got historic flair, solid design, and spa-caliber features in this lovely home.
Historic Townhouse
Speaking of great design and copper soaking tubs, this historic townhouse offers a similar setup, except it comes with three rooms. (From what I can tell, this unit shares the same property with the rental above, but the hosts aren’t listed as the same on Vrbo.) Expect a bold, upscale design that comes with comfortable, modern features, along with a fantastic location close to Old Mistick Village and the marina.
1890s Downtown Mystic House
This 1890s home has been fully renovated in 2022 with modern updates, letting you sleep up to six guests in a two-bedroom-plus-an-office setup. It’s nestled right in the heart of Mystic, letting you park the car and forget about the keys for a few days. The backyard also has views of Mystic River, while a separate courtyard area with a fire pit gives you the perfect place to unwind after a long day. They’re also a fantastic place to hang out and enjoy the autumn weather.
Historic House in Downtown Mystic
Though it looks small from the outside, this newly renovated home is perfect for groups as large as eight. There are three bedrooms, along with a double futon sofa bed in the living room. Aside from an abundance of sleeping areas, this home also has a cozy living room-kitchen setup that makes hanging out comfortable for everyone. Out back, there’s a separate dining area where your group can eat while enjoying the crisp autumn breeze. Lastly, this is a historic home, meaning you’ll notice plenty of character throughout, like the bespoke staircase that dates back to the 1700s.
Arden House
If you prefer an all-white, spa-like setup, this luxury three-bedroom home offers a calming respite. The kitchen is fully equipped with high-end appliances, ideal for those who like to cook. Plus, the Arden House is located in historic downtown Mystic, giving you a wonderfully walkable location.
Sea Captain’s House
The best Vrbos in Mystic, Connecticut usually give a nod to the area’s maritime history, but this rental goes all-in on the city’s nautical past. The home has three bedrooms, each of which comes with its own theme (periwinkle for the kids’ room, naturally). Throughout, you’ll find nautical décor that’s tasteful rather than kitschy. The home also has a back patio with a sea glass fire pit, where you can kick back at your leisure while enjoying views of the water.
Charming 1845 Home
As with nautical themes, you’ll find that many Vrbos in Mystic are chock-full of charm. But this 1845 home has a wonderful balance of historic features with homely additions that make it memorably warm and charming. From the bookcases to the exposed brick, you’ll feel comfortable in no time in this two-bedroom. As an added bonus, it’s located in the heart of Mystic’s historic district, giving you walkability and a scenic area to explore.
Boho Retreat
Fresh, modern, and with all the creature comforts you could look for, this Boho Retreat has it all. Aside from its high-end interior, you’ve got a solid location in downtown Mystic, located near its top attractions. Just know that there’s only one bathroom.
Harbor View Landing
This cottage is one of several on the property, which is located right on the water. Its small studio setup is perfect for couples, while its waterfront setting is ideal for those who like to listen to the waves. There’s also a small sitting area outside where you can soak up the scenery. Just make sure to bring your scarf in autumn—it’ll get chilly.
[Just a heads-up: We may earn an affiliate commission when you make a purchase from a link in our articles.]
