23 Gifts Everyone Will Fight Over At Your White Elephant Party

“My friends love wine — we rarely get together without opening a bottle or two. While I am a fan of the tried and true corkscrew style, the new electric wine openers are so much easier. There is no twisting, pulling, or leveraging — you simply push a button. Over the years; we have tested many wine openers; many require a certain amount of hand strength to operate. The electric opener’s corkscrew slides into the cork with the push of a button and extracts the cork. Then the opener goes in reverse to unscrew the cork. It’s almost as much fun as enjoying a glass of wine — almost.” — Sandi Barrett

“This is perfect for all those times you find yourself at outdoor events. Whether you’re at an outdoor concert or spending the day beachside, this extra-large blanket comes in handy — it’s a nice spot for our four-legged friends to hang out as well. This blanket is water-resistant, so if the grass is a little dewy, no worries, and it folds up nicely so it’s totally portable. You just never know when you’re going to need a large, lightweight blanket!” — SJ Morgensen

“This is a fun White Elephant gift, gag gift, or stocking stuffer. This LED motion toilet light sits on the rim of your commode and activates as soon as you approach the toilet. It is LED, so the colors are vivid. You can change to different colors with the flip of a switch. If you have ever tried to go to the bathroom in the dark, you know it can be a pain, and turning on bright lights hurts your eyes. This toilet light will glow and make your life — and if you’re a man, ‘your aim’ — easier. It is also a great conversation starter when people visit your bathroom and use your glowing bowl. The toilet light is battery-operated and has 16 different color options. You can have a different colored bathroom experience every night for over two weeks.” — Robin O’Neal Smith

“We all know that person who loves squirting lighter fluid into the flames. This is the perfect nontoxic alternative. If your family and friend group includes regular campers or a few folks who like to enjoy a crackling fire out on the deck or patio, this will be the coveted White Elephant item they’ve never seen before.

When I first heard about Pull Start Fire, it sounded too good to be true, but after just one ‘pull,’ my sister, our overlanding friend Ciara, and I were converted. You literally wrap the designated loop of string around one of your fire logs, pull another string, and in less than a minute, your fire is building. The company claims Pull Start Fire even lights wet wood, though we tested it with a cord of fresh, dry Snugglewood.” — Linsey Stevens, Managing Editor

“You can’t go wrong with Goodr sunglasses. These will 100 percent get stolen at a White Elephant party because they look good on everyone. At my last party, it was fun watching everyone try these on.

I used to buy expensive sunglasses, but I’d either scratch or lose them. And the worst part was that they’d always end up falling off my nose or getting stuck in my hair. Then I found Goodr. They’re designed for athletes, but they’re super cute and come in a bunch of different colors and styles. They have stayed on my face through a half marathon and they’re cheap enough that I can keep a couple of pairs around to throw on for any occasion. I cannot recommend these enough!” — Kasey Grelle, CEO

“This journal planner is my favorite product of 2022! I don’t know about you, but I live and die by my handwritten planner, so it has to be small enough to fit in my purse. In an effort to be more mindful, I have also made journaling a priority. Not only is this Rocketbook Core the perfect size, it combines both planner pages with journaling pages. But wait — there’s more! This notebook is completely sustainable and you can reuse the pages over and over. Simply use the Rocketbook pen (included with purchase), scan the page once complete, and your notes will be uploaded to your email address, Dropbox, or Cloud. Then, wipe the page clean! Rocketbook gets an A+ for helping anyone organize their life and it’s so fun watching people ‘ooh and ahh’ at its smart technology.” — Allison Weston, Director of Marketing

“This Tile tracker was the most stolen gift at my family holiday party! Does that mean we’re all forgetful? Thankfully, I ended up taking home this prize, and I’m so glad I did. I slipped this onto my key ring and never have to worry about losing my keys again. I even bought the sleek sticker version to use on my TV remote and my Roomba (ALWAYS under the bed!).

Pro Tip: You can also throw one in your checked luggage when traveling to make sure your bags make it on the plane, and to know when your bag is coming out of the baggage carousel.” — Nicole McCulloch, Brand Director

“These may look super cheesy, because they are, but I can personally attest to the fact they’ll be a hit at any women’s White Elephant party. Each Drinking Buddy comes with his own name and, aside from being good for a laugh, these are actually quite useful to keep track of your glass at a larger party. Pair them with a good bottle of wine or nice set of wine glasses,  and this may be the top stolen gift of the night.” — Allison Weston, Director of Marketing

“Whether you’re traveling or running errands around town, you can never have too many good reusable bags. Blue Q’s shoulder totes take reusable bags to the next level with a sturdy design, external pocket, cheeky prints, and zip closure. Select the right print for your White Elephant crowd, and it’s guaranteed that this is the gift any recipient will use.” — Linsey Stevens, Managing Editor

“This slick wine carrier will be the gift that’s stolen a few times at your holiday gathering, especially if you include a bottle or two of wine. The Tirrinia wine tote is perfect to take to a picnic or a friend’s house where it’s BYOB. It comes in a variety of colors, perfect for all tastes. Tirrinia also makes single- and four-bottle totes, so there’s something for everyone.” — Missy Glassmaker, SVP

“Anyone at your White Elephant gift exchange would be lucky to go home with this awesome float — although they may have to wait a while to use it! It is compact, so you can bring it along on your beach vacation. It is super easy to inflate, too. Plus, the hammock style keeps you comfy instead of trying to stay on. At under $13, this is a great option for those who are on a budget.” — Laura Ray, Content Strategist